Sunday, October 17, 2010

Best Romance Novels Part 1

I've decided to start my research into the best romance novels with Outlander (as it's known in the US) or Cross Stitch (as it's known in the UK and Aus) by Diana Gabaldon. It's on lots of 'best of' lists for romance novels, so I thought it would be a great one to start with, especially as most readers/reviewers seem to love and treasure it.


Now, it's not a typical romance novel, or certainly not what I would consider typical. It's a real mix of history with time travel and a slow building romance. There are also two heroes which will may be a bit strange for readers (I will admit I had a bit of an issue with this initially), and the connection between Frank and his rather creepy ancestor lends a kind of oddness to the story (for me, anyway!).

The detail is amazing, and it's obvious Diana did a lot of research into the Scottish time period she set the majority of the book in. I love history, but as I was after romance, I found myself getting a little tired of waiting for some action in that area. Once the romance really began, I thoroughly enjoyed the ride, and found Claire to be an interesting heroine. Jamie, her highlander lover, possesses the wonderful qualities of a romantic hero - attractive, brave, loyal, loving and dedicated to the heroine.

Diana can certainly tell a wonderful story, and knows how to suck a reader into the world she has created. Although I can understand why people love this book (and I will HAVE to buy the rest of the series as I need to know how it all plays out!), I don't know whether I'd consider this one of my favourite romance novels of all time. It's partly to do with my issue with Claire's relationship with Frank being unresolved/rather murky. I won't explain further as this will ruin it for readers who haven't read the book, but if you have, you'll know what I mean. I'm interested to see if people have an issue with this at all, but I felt Claire didn't pine after her husband enough, in my opinion.

All in all, it's a fantastic book and well worth reading, but if you are after a classic romance, this may not quite fit the bill. As I've mentioned before, I'll definitely get the rest of the series, however I won't have the expectation that it'll pan out like a typical romance with a HEA. I could be wrong, but I look forward to finding out if I am.

Happy reading,

:-) Mon

4 comments:

Rachael Johns said...

Ooh a friend of mine raved about this book and your review has made me think I should give it a go. Will add it to the To Buy/Borrow list :)

Mon said...

Rach, it's a great read, but don't be surprised if you have a few issues with it. The again, you may not have any issues with it, but I can't go into too much detail without giving the plot away! Lol.

Let me know what you think when you finish (chances are you'll want to borrow/buy the rest of the series like I do!).

Cathryn Brunet said...

I used to work with a lady who LOVED this series and couldn't stop raving about it. Really must get around to reading it myself one day.

One day...when my to-be-read pile isn't so huge!

Mon said...

Cathryn, I know what you mean about the TBR pile - this book was sitting there for a while because I have a massive pile to get through! Gives me a headache just looking at it.

The advantage of getting hooked so late to a series is that you don't have to wait for the next book to come out because it's been out for years. Yay! :-)